Based on the Podcast Episode: “Under the Streetlights: Andrew McCrorie-Shand on Writing from Image, Emotion and Imagination“ – Episode 61, The Magic of Songwriting with Francesca de Valence

What a gift it was to sit down with a songwriter who has lived so many musical lives. In my recent conversation with Andrew McCrorie-Shand , I was struck not only by his incredible career – from prog rock to film scores to a #1 hit with Teletubbies – but by the simple and effective ways he continues to approach his songwriting practice. 

Listen below for the full sonic experience, or read below for the key takeaways from our conversation that might spark something for you.

1. Picture the scene

Andy approaches songwriting like he approaches film scoring. Imagining the scene first and asking, “Where’s the camera?” This opens up story, emotion and imagery straight away.

Give it a go: Before you write your next song, close your eyes and imagine the film shot. Is it a close-up, a wide view, day or night? Show that picture with your words.

2. Write quickly, then walk away

Andy spends 10–15 minutes sketching out music then leaves it for a few days. By the time he comes back, the subconscious has already been at work and the song just flows.

Give it a go: Next time you get your Club prompt, put something down fast – even if it feels rough – then step away. Trust that more will be ready for you when you return.

3. Keep it simple, keep it honest

For Andy, simplicity equals honesty. Stripping things back lets the emotion shine through.

Give it a go: Play your song with just one voice and one instrument. Does the story and feeling still hold up? If so, you know the heart of the song is there.

4. Stay in practice

Even after decades in the music industry, Andy still writes a song every week in I Heart Songwriting Club. He calls it a songwriter’s gym – a way to stay fit and ready.

Give it a go: Don’t wait for the next album project to start writing and growing your songwriting muscles. Keep writing regularly, stay songwriting fit, and you’ll always have a bank of songs to draw from when opportunity knocks.

Andy’s 2025 album Songs is made almost entirely of tracks he wrote in the Club. Proof that with regular practice, simple tools and trust in the process, beautiful work can emerge. Listen to that album here.

Looking for help to write your next album?

If you are looking for your songwriting community for accountability, support and guidance to write your next album, check out our Songwriting Club and Courses here.